NESTLED AT THE HEART OF EDGARTOWN, where the salty breeze of Marta’s Vineyard’s shores meets the vibrant pulse of the Triangle, Edgartown Pizza stands as a culinary beacon for locals and visitors alike.
While its name suggests a singular focus, this family-style gem offers a menu so diverse and inviting that it redefines what a “pizza place” can be. From gourmet pizzas to gluten-free delights, hearty burgers to Brazilian-inspired dishes, Edgartown Pizza is a testament to the island’s inclusive, community-driven spirit. Here, every bite tells a story of flavor, creativity, and connection.
A Slice of Something for Everyone
Pizza is undeniably the star at Edgartown Pizza, and with over 55 varieties, there’s a pie for every palate. Classics like the Meat Lover’s and Buffalo Chicken share the spotlight with inventive options like the Edgartown Veggie, loaded with peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives. For those with dietary preferences, the restaurant shines with its gluten-free and cauliflower-crust pizzas, ensuring no one misses out on the joy of a perfectly baked slice. Any pizza on the menu can be ordered with a gluten-free crust, and it’s just as delicious. And for a quick bite or snack, just grab a slice and soda to go.
But the magic of Edgartown Pizza extends far beyond its namesake. The menu is a vibrant tapestry of flavors, weaving together comfort food staples and unexpected delights. Craving something lighter? Their salads are a revelation—think crisp romaine Caesar topped with grilled chicken or steak, or a mixed green salad bursting with fruits, guacamole, and house-made vinaigrette. For heartier appetites, the burgers, served on brioche buns with creative toppings like blue cheese, bacon, and fried eggs, are a standout.
The Blue Cheeseburger is a local favorite, paired perfectly with a side of golden, crunchy fries. Grilled Goodies and Global Inspirations Edgartown Pizza’s “From the Grill” section is where things get truly exciting. The Teriyaki Steak Tips, a generous portion, are marinated to perfection and served with rice and salad—easily enough for two, and a special treat not expected from a pizza place.
Sandwiches and wraps, customizable with toppings like lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, and provolone, cater to those seeking a handheld feast. Options like the marinated grilled chicken sandwich with sun-dried tomato pesto or the classic BLT on toasted multigrain are as satisfying as they are diverse.
The menu also nods to global influences, particularly with its Brazilian lunch offerings. Brazilian-style rice and beans accompany dishes like grilled chicken or steak, adding a cultural twist that reflects the island’s diverse community.
It’s all about making everyone, visitors and locals alike, feel at home. What sets Edgartown Pizza apart isn’t just its food—it’s the heart behind it.
Open daily from 10:30 a.m. to 9:00 p.m., this year-round eatery is a haven for families and individuals alike.
MORE INFO
224 Edgartown-Vineyard Haven Rd.
Edgartown
(508) 627-7770
edgartownpizza.com
